コラム:パリジェンヌの東京映画レポート2 - 第6回




Movies are telling stories but also expressing concepts. Often, those concepts are timeless, and need therefore to be re-told to be transmitted to the younger generations. Remaking a movie is therefore a way of paying tribute to the original movie, while transmitting its message to other generations.

Thus, Louis Malle’s first fiction feature movie “L’ascenseur pour l’echafaud” ( Lift To The Scaffold), which came out in 1958 will now reappear in a Japanese and modernized version under the name “Shikeidai no elevator”. Making a remake, especially the remake of a movie considered as a masterpiece of the French cinema was a challenge but also an honor for the Japanese director Akira Ogata.

How does Ogata’s “Shikeidai no elevator” retell “L’ascenseur pour l’echafaud” ‘s story?


First of all, the scenarios of both movies are really similar. Just as its original, “Shikeidai no elevator” deals with three connected plots: Julien Tavernier/Tokito trapped in the elevator near the murder scene, Florence Carala/ Meiko wandering in the streets at night searching for her lover, and a young delinquent couple escaping with a stolen car. Even though the story takes place half a century later and in another country, the differences regarding the plot are almost inexistent.

Then, one of the strong elements of the original movie was that Louis Malle humanized his intrigue and his characters through close-ups and the off-screen voice of the heroine. This way of focusing on the characters and building the plot around the feelings of the protagonists is also present in the Japanese version.
Thus, the two movies open for instance on the same scene: a close-up on the heroine who's on the phone with her lover, telling him that she loves him and urging him to finally kill her husband so they can be together…

And yet, even though those elements make the remake pretty similar to Malle’s movie, you don’t leave the theatre with the same feelings.

While Akira Ogata's shooting can indeed be compared to Malle's one, through the close-ups and the use of lights and shadows that create a special atmosphere, the transmission of some scenes is quite different and reflects how cinema has changed within 50 years. In fact, it is striking, once you saw the 50’s version of the movie, how much more aggressive and explicit the thriller is today. But can we blame Ogata for it? I don't think so. Imagine he had filmed the story like Malle did: first, wouldn’t you think "how old-fashioned!", second, is there a point in remaking a movie without adapting it to the present? I don’t think so.
I reckon that what makes out a successful remake is also that the concepts of the original movie are correctly translated into the present, with a modern shooting and staging. It has to be an original in its way.

アンニュイな雰囲気を 漂わせていたジャンヌ・モロー
アンニュイな雰囲気を 漂わせていたジャンヌ・モロー

On top of that, even though the two movie directors put the feminine protagonist in the foreground through close-ups and the off-voice, one of the biggest differences between both movie versions may nevertheless lay in this character. In fact, while Jeanne Moreau plays a fragile and romantic woman, Kichise Michiko seems to personify a strong woman and her passion for her lover is less visible, she almost seems heartless sometimes. I guess that this gives more intensity to the plot and reflects how the role of women in society has changed nowadays.

But even if Malle’s movie doesn’t have the attributes of a modern thriller you can nevertheless feel the suspense and the intensity of the happening thanks to something which is undoubtedly one of the most impressive elements of Malle’s movie: the music.

Indeed, Miles Davis, who improvised directly while viewing the movie, managed perfectly to catch the spirit of the scenes and to express it all with a jazzy soundtrack which has been highly praised and described by jazz critic Phil Johnson as “"the loneliest trumpet sound you will ever hear, and the model for sad-core music ever since. Hear it and weep". Malle's "L'ascenseur pour l'echafaud" would doubtlessly not have been the same without Miles Davis!

This may be the only regret you could have while watching Ogata’s “Lift to the Scaffold”. Because all the other differences seem necessary to make the movie adapted to our time. A Japanese remake, but above all a contemporary remake.






緒方監督の撮り方は、マル監督の撮り方と比べると、同じクローズアップでも雰囲気がまったく異なっていて、映画は50年でこんなにも変わったのかということを思い知らされます。実際、50年代に撮られたオリジナルは、今日のスリラーよりずっと挑戦的な作品です。だからといって、緒方監督を責めることは出来ません。もし、緒方監督がマル監督と同じように撮っていたら、多くの観客は「古くさい」と思ったはずです。それに、まったく同じやり方で撮ることにリメイクする意味などあるでしょうか? 私は映画のリメイクを成功させる秘訣は、その映画のコンセプトを現代に正確に置き換えることだと考えます。そうすれば、それはオリジナルになるはずなのです。









  1. 「RRR」超えの大ヒット! インド映画の最終兵器「K.G.F: CHAPTER 1&2」7月14日公開


    「RRR」超えの大ヒット! インド映画の最終兵器「K.G.F: CHAPTER 1&2」7月14日公開

    2023年6月5日 12:00
  2. 「劇場版TOKYO MER」観客動員300万人、興行収入40億円突破!“発声可能応援上映”も全国拡大


    「劇場版TOKYO MER」観客動員300万人、興行収入40億円突破!“発声可能応援上映”も全国拡大

    2023年6月5日 13:00
  3. 舞台「フルーツバスケット 2nd season」新キャスト5人発表 草摩慊人役に元宝塚・彩凪翔


    舞台「フルーツバスケット 2nd season」新キャスト5人発表 草摩慊人役に元宝塚・彩凪翔

    2023年6月5日 07:30
  4. 橋本環奈×重岡大毅「禁じられた遊び」 美雪を演じているのは誰?ビジュアル第3弾&キャスト本人からのメッセージ動画公開


    橋本環奈×重岡大毅「禁じられた遊び」 美雪を演じているのは誰?ビジュアル第3弾&キャスト本人からのメッセージ動画公開

    2023年6月5日 06:00
  5. 「翔んで埼玉II」埼玉&千葉解放戦線のキャラクターが再登場 加藤諒、益若つばさらが続投


    「翔んで埼玉II」埼玉&千葉解放戦線のキャラクターが再登場 加藤諒、益若つばさらが続投

    2023年6月5日 12:00